How to Get the Most Out of a Reference Check

When it comes time to check references, plenty of companies are tempted to just skip it. They've pretty much decided to extend an offer, and nobody provides a reference who's going to say anything bad, right? So what's the point?

We think that’s the wrong mindset. Instead of treating the reference check like the last opportunity to catch a potential problem, use it as the tool it is! A strategic reference check probably won't change whether or not a company extends an offer, but it can completely change how well the new hire’s first months with the company go. Most organizations could be doing more with these calls.

WHY THE REFERENCE CHECK ISN’T A GATEKEEPING STEP

Consider how references work. A savvy candidate offers up people they’re confident they have a great relationship with, so of course those people are going to speak highly of them. Framing the reference check around whether you should hire the candidate just isn't going to do you much good.

It's no wonder a lot of companies opt to skip, but they shouldn't! The question these calls should primarily be used to answer is a much more useful one: what do you wish you'd known before you hired this person? Reframed that way, a reference check can be used as a roadmap for the manager who is hoping they'll hit the ground running.

THE REFERENCE CHECK QUESTIONS WORTH ASKING

Most reference calls are over in five or ten minutes because most recruiters ask the obvious questions: How long did you work together? Would you hire them again? Boring! Those questions have obvious answers, and they teach you almost nothing.

Ours tend to run closer to half an hour, because we're digging for more useful information for a company that already knows they want to hire. 

The three questions we find can define a candidate-turned-new-hire's early weeks with the company:

  • What should this person's future manager know about them?

  • If you had to give one piece of advice to their future manager about managing them successfully, what would it be?

  • How does this person like to receive feedback?

For a manager who only knows a candidate from a few interviews, the responses we get can be absolute gold. They help prepare them to communicate effectively with the new member of their team, give them an idea of how to coach them well, and help them start building a good relationship from week one.

From there, we tailor the rest of the questions to the role or the individual. We'll ask things like:

  • What kinds of projects genuinely light this person up?

  • Do they tend to thrive more in team settings or working independently?

  • How do they handle themselves when priorities suddenly shift?

  • How do they balance speed against quality?

  • How do they approach testing or scaling something new?

Questions like these help their new manager plan for what to put on their plate early so they can come out of the gates swinging, to the benefit of both the company and the new hire themselves. Every answer is another piece of the puzzle that will set the new team up for early wins.

HOW A REFERENCE CHECK SETS A NEW HIRE UP FOR SUCCESS

We recently placed someone who'd spent her entire career (including five promotions!) at a single company. She had a truly incredible run there, but it made for a nervous hire on both sides. She'd never worked anywhere else, which comes with its own anxiety, and the client had never seen her operate outside one environment.

It also made references a little trickier to gather. When you've only worked at one place, who do you list without sounding the alarm that you're looking? 

We worked with her to find former managers who had since moved on but had worked with her closely and could speak freely about their experience. Those conversations gave us a detailed read on how she liked to be managed, how she took feedback, and the kind of environment where she did her best work.

We took the intel straight to her new team, and she's been thriving in the role (at least in part) because of it. She started about six months ago, and she's on track to be promoted within her first year! We certainly can't claim the references did all of that. She's exceptional on her own. But we're confident the depth of those calls is a real part of why her first six months went so smoothly.

WHY WE NEVER SKIP THE REFERENCE CHECK

When both sides already see they have a great match, it’s tempting to just skip the reference check entirely. But we'd argue for the opposite. A great fit is exactly why the reference call is important.

A thorough reference process signals something to everyone involved. To the candidate, it says the company is serious enough to do real diligence so they get the right person in the seat. Even if it feels like one more hoop, this tends to build confidence rather than erode it. To the hiring team, it's a head start on a relationship they'll be building for years. Done well, it de-risks those crucial first days when a new hire is finding their footing on a new team.

The reference check is the first page of the playbook for working together well. Skip it, and you're leaving valuable insights on the table at the exact moment they could have helped the most.

Previous
Previous

What Makes a Recruiter Great? Lessons from the Other Side of the Table

Next
Next

What A Long-Term Recruiter Relationship Actually Buys You